Individual Reflections 2

​

I was the stakeholder leader for developing Round 2 of proposing a challenge. Since mental health is a significant factor in students' success, I have chosen this area as my proposal. Middle school can be a particularly challenging and confusing period for many students, including myself. As a result, I proposed a challenge to Team 3 titled:

​

Improving Mental Health Support and Social-Emotional Learning (SEL) Integration in Middle School Education.

​

Round 2 of the Stakeholder Challenge Proposals offered a valuable opportunity to explore mental health and the integration of Social-Emotional Learning (SEL) for middle school students. I gained insights and noted essential aspects during this process.

​

Learning Experiences

​

This round taught me the importance of balancing resolutions with feasibility when designing solutions for middle school education. Our team (Team 1) discussed potential solutions and anticipated Team 3's response to our challenge. One agreement among team members was to ensure we do not overwhelm teachers, avoid relying on untrained individuals, and refrain from imposing extra costs on schools for hiring specialists.

​

The proposal included five key components: partnerships with mental health professionals, comprehensive teacher training, parent engagement, student-led initiatives (such as sharing personal journeys through blogs), and continuous evaluation. Each of these components presented unique challenges that required careful consideration.

​

The cultural and community diversity reflected in the challenges truly resonated with me. It underscored the necessity of adaptability in any program, ensuring it stays relevant and practical for various school demographics. This realization served as a powerful reminder of the importance of including stakeholders during the design phase, and we had to remind Team 3 to consider this.

​

Insights

​

A critical insight from this round is the challenge of integrating Social and Emotional Learning (SEL) into classroom routines without overwhelming teachers or disrupting existing curricula. Teachers already have demanding schedules, so incorporating SEL components requires careful strategies to ensure their commitment and the smooth integration of these practices. A successful solution must provide teachers with the necessary tools and build their confidence and willingness to adopt SEL practices. My approach involved training art teachers to incorporate mental health and well-being lessons into art classes. However, in their response, Team 3 had a different perspective on addressing this issue, which we found impractical.

​

Additionally, while the proposal suggested student-led initiatives, I recognized the importance of considering the dynamics of middle school. Empowering students is crucial, but without clear guidelines, training, and oversight, initiatives such as peer support groups could unintentionally create power imbalances or reinforce cliques. This insight underscored the need to design these programs with built-in safeguards and ongoing supervision.

​

Remarks

​

Measuring the success of mental health programs is one of the most complex challenges we face. Even my two team members admitted that their schools don't have a measuring system to assess students' mental health progress.

​

Although the proposal requests both quantitative and qualitative indicators, I was considering specific tools and strategies for effective data collection during its development. To address this concern, it's essential to establish clear metrics, such as student surveys, attendance patterns, and academic engagement data, to evaluate the programs effectively.

​

Another consideration was to avoid heavy reliance on community partnerships and parents. While these are valuable resources, an implementation might face barriers such as confidentiality of mental health data and the requirements for nonparent volunteers to access such information.

​

Overall Reflections

​

This round deepened my understanding of interconnected resources, stakeholders, and implementation strategies. Effective solutions need to consider schools' practical limitations while also addressing the diverse needs of students, teachers, and families. Collaborating with all stakeholders is essential for creating meaningful and sustainable change.